American
Splendor
1/2
American
Splendor
is one of the best movies based on a comic book I've ever
seen. But, unlike X-Men, Spider-Man, or Hulk,
there are no superheroes to be found. Instead, it revolves
around underground comic book legend Harvey Pekar, who is
as far from a typical comic hero as you could get. He is neurotic,
obsessive/compulsive, and hopelessly pessimistic. The fact
that he is a real person makes him a fascinating character
to base a film around.
Co-directors
Shari Springer Berman and Robert Pulcini had already directed
several documentaries, and that experience shows. Made for
a trivial amount of money, American Splendor is part
drama, part comedy, and part documentary. The meat of the
movie revolves around Harvey Pekar as played by character
actor Paul Giamatti, but these sequences are interspersed
with footage of interviews that the film-makers held with
Pekar, and the film is narrated by the real Harvey Pekar,
who always acknowledges this is a film about him ("And
this is the guy playing me," he says of Giamatti at one
point). Pekar's wife, Joyce Brabner (Hope Davis), his adopted
daughter, Danielle (Madylin Sweeten), and his nerdy friend,
Toby Radloff (Judah Friedlander), are all given the same treatment
as Harvey.
One
would think that this rather unconventional approach would
hurt the film's character development. This is not the case,
however, as the great screenplay and the wonderful acting
make the transitions unimportant. Because all of the actors
have inhabited their roles completely, it quickly becomes
meaningless whether it's the real person or an actor on the
screen at the moment.
Pekar's
comic book, "American Splendor", will not be known
to many Americans. It was started in 1976, with Pekar writing
(he can't even draw stick figures well) and comic legend R.
Crumb doing the illustrations. The approach he took was radically
different from anything else that had come before; instead
of superheroes or anthropomorphic animals, "American
Splendor" was centered around Harvey and his everyday
life working as a file clerk at a hospital. They never really
caught on (and still haven't, even with Dark Horse comics
handling the distribution), but over time they found a strong
cult following. This resulted in several memorable appearances
on the "Late Show with David Letterman" before Pekar
attacked NBC (Letterman's station at the time) and GE, who
sponsored the "Late Show", and was never asked back.
Since then, he has become better known through writing and
radio, but he isn't exactly a house-hold name.
With
two exceptions, American Splendor takes place entirely
in the 1970's and '80s. It details his years before "Splendor";
his second failed marriage;the beginning years of "Splendor";
his marriage to Joyce, his third wife; and his successful
battle with cancer (chronicled in the comic "Our Cancer
Years", written by Harvey and Joyce). We are also introduced
to Toby Radloff and other mainstays from Pekar's comics.
There
are plenty of visual tweaks used to spice up the film. One
of the most remarkable sequences in American Splendor occurs
when Harvey (as played by Giamatti) steps into the middle
of a blank white screen. As he begins to speak, lines appear
in the background; soon, he is standing in the middle of a
giant comic book panel. A window appears behind him, opening
into the real world. He steps through the window, into the
snow, and, as he walks, continues to speak. He steps back
into the comic as he finishes up. This scene represents a
triumph of acting, writing, and visual effects. Giamatti delivers
a soliloquy worthy of Shakespeare; detailing a time when he
found several other Harvey Pekars in the phone book, he ruminates
on life and existance. The technology used in this sequence
is not perfect, but it is on the level of many mainstream
films. There are many other points in which the world of comics
and the real world collide (many of the scene transitions
are labeled with panels reading "Two weeks later...",
etc.), and on at least one occasion, animated characters appear
onscreen with the actors.
The
acting is stellar. Paul Giamatti, despite not really looking
like Pekar (the film recognizes this on one occasion), invests
himself in the character, mastering all of the real Harvey's
expressions and mannerisms. As he walks down the street, scowling
and silently muttering to himself, we don't need any sort
of dialogue to instantly get a feel for the character. This
is a career-making performance. As Harvey's wife, Hope Davis
is just about as good as Giamatti. Like Giamatti, she captures
all of her character's neuroses with ease. Nearly all of the
supporting performances are equally excellent.
American
Splendor
has already been one of the year's most acclaimed movies,
winning the top prize for drama at Sundance and the FIPRESCI
Award at Cannes. It certainly deserves these honors. It is
a stunningly original, mostly brilliant character study. Going
into the film, I knew close to nothing about the life of Harvey
Pekar; as I left, I felt like I knew him personally, and I
couldn't wait to learn more about him. How many 100 minute
films - let alone biopics - can claim to have an effect like
that? Not many - American Splendor is a rare find.
©
2003 Matt Noller
|
|